
Has Your New Business Pipeline Slowed? Maybe It’s Been Diverted Elsewhere.
I’ve worked in advertising agency business development for decades. I’ve witnessed recessions, mergers, the growth of digital agencies, media splitting off, and plenty of predictions that traditional agencies would disappear.
One thing has stayed the same through all of this: companies look for outside experts to help them grow, and agencies try to find those companies before their competitors do. That part hasn’t changed. But I’m starting to wonder if some of our usual ways of finding new business are becoming less reliable.
More and more agency owners tell me their pipelines are slowing down. Prospects don’t respond as often. Opportunities that used to look promising now take longer to develop. Even with all the prospecting tools we have, finding good new business isn’t any easier. People usually say it’s because marketing budgets are tight, competition is tough, and companies don’t want to switch agencies. Those are all fair points. But what if there’s something else going on?
What if the opportunities you’re searching for haven’t gone away? What if they’re just turning up in different places?
The market isn’t acting like it used to.
Look at what’s happening in marketing right now. Brands are trying out AI-generated creative, building their own teams, combining agency relationships, and rethinking which outside services they really need. Marketing leaders are expected to deliver more growth with fewer resources. Decisions that used to be made mostly by marketing are now influenced by procurement, finance, technology, and top executives.
None of these changes are completely new. What’s different now is how fast they’re coming together. An agency that used to compete for a traditional ad assignment might now be up against an in-house creative team, a specialized consultancy, a tech platform, or even a mix of all three.
At the same time, when a company hires a new marketing leader, restructures its team, enters a new market, or invests in new skills, it might be creating an agency opportunity without saying so publicly. That’s what I find interesting. I’m not asking if the traditional agency search is dead. I’m searching for the signs that come before an agency opportunity is changing, and if our usual prospecting methods aren’t picking up on these new signals.
The pitch might be decided before it even starts.
A few years ago, I surveyed over 150 marketing decision-makers at both B2B and B2C companies about how they choose advertising agencies. One question stood out: When during the pitch process do marketers know which agency they want to hire?
The results were eye-opening. Seventy-one percent said they sometimes knew which agency would win before the pitch even started. Another 13% said they had already made up their minds. Only 16% waited until the end of the process to decide. One marketer told me, “Through the process, I often settle on a favorite, so the pitch is really theirs to lose.” That has big implications for agency business development.
Agencies invest a lot of time and money preparing credentials, building strategies, and practicing presentations, often thinking the competition is fair. But the marketer may have already picked a favorite long before the final presentation. My research didn’t pinpoint exactly when or how those preferences form, but it left me with a question I’ve been considering ever since.
If the decision is often made before the pitch, shouldn’t we focus more of our business development efforts on what happens before we’re even invited? You can read the original study research in my article, Is an Agency Pitch a Fair Fight?.
That question matters even more today. Marketers can now research agencies on their own using Google, LinkedIn, industry publications, referrals, agency websites, and more often, AI tools. They can check out capabilities, compare experience, and make a shortlist without ever reaching out to an agency.
But before any of that, something inside the company sparks the need for outside help. I think this is where agency business development needs to get smarter.
The agency search might have already started without you realizing it.
Think about what goes on inside a company before they decide to look for a new advertising agency. Maybe sales are down. A competitor is gaining ground. A new CMO wants to take things in a new direction. A product launch isn’t working out. An acquisition brings new brands, markets, and customers to handle. Or the CEO asks marketing to do more with less.
These situations don’t always lead straight to an agency review. First, leaders have to see the problem, agree that change is needed, and decide if they need outside help. That process can take weeks or months. Once they decide to look outside, the company starts researching agencies without letting them know. Recent data shows companies may get through up to 80% of the buying process before reaching out.
I think this part of the process deserves more focus from agency business development leaders. According to the 2025 Agency New Year Outlook Report from RSW/US, 48% of marketers surveyed are now running more agency searches themselves instead of using search consultants.
That brings up an important question. If more marketers are handling their own searches, how can agencies find opportunities that never show up in the trade press or sales platforms? More importantly, how do we get considered before the prospect decides who to reach out to?
Focus on finding the problem, not just the pitch.
Most agencies make prospect lists based on industry, company revenue, marketing budgets, and executive titles. These are helpful, but they don’t explain why a company might need an agency right now. Business situations do.
If a manufacturer announces a big product expansion, they might need new positioning, customer research, and marketing support. A retailer losing younger customers may need to rethink its brand. A financial institution moving into new markets may need to build awareness and preference where it’s not well known. These are business problems worth looking into, even if they’re not confirmed agency opportunities yet.
This is where AI can make agency research much more effective. Start with a list of 25 or 50 companies that match your ideal client. Use an AI research tool that can access up-to-date web sources to check recent earnings reports, leadership changes, marketing job postings, acquisitions, product launches, and industry news. Ask it to find developments that might create a need for your expertise. Make sure you get dated sources, supporting evidence, and other possible explanations. Then look for patterns.
A new CMO is interesting. But a new CMO joining a company with falling sales and hiring a director of brand transformation is even more interesting. Neither one proves the company is looking for an agency, but together, they give you a stronger reason to look into it and maybe reach out.
Watch for signs that the search might already be happening.
Marketing job descriptions can tell you a lot. Check LinkedIn Jobs, Indeed, and company career pages for phrases like “agency selection,” “agency evaluation,” “vendor consolidation,” “external partners,” “creative agency management,” and “marketing transformation.” If a company is hiring someone to review agency relationships, it’s worth a closer look. But be cautious—the same company might also be building its own team to replace outside services.
What executives are doing can give you more insight. Follow marketing leaders at your target companies. See what they’re talking about, the challenges they mention, the conferences they attend, and the priorities they announce. Industry publications, company news, and investor presentations can also give you helpful context.
Don’t forget to check your own website. If someone keeps visiting your case studies or capabilities pages, it could mean they’re interested, even if you can’t always tell who it is. When you can link this activity to a target account, it’s another helpful clue. The goal isn’t to find one perfect sign of an agency review—it’s to connect several clues that suggest a company might be rethinking its marketing.
Be sure prospects can find you when they start searching.
There’s another angle to consider. While you’re looking up prospects, they might be researching agencies. They could search Google, ask colleagues for recommendations, read industry publications, check out agency case studies, or use ChatGPT and other AI tools to find firms with the right expertise.
Have you ever tried searching for your own agency the way a potential client would? Not by name, but by asking for independent agencies with proven experience solving the problems your agency handles best. See which agencies come up. Check why they’re recommended and look at the sources behind those recommendations.
Take a look at your website, case studies, executive commentary, and third-party references. Do they give enough credible evidence to put you on that list? If not, there’s work to be done. AI visibility can’t replace reputation, referrals, or relationships, but it’s quickly becoming another way agencies are evaluated before anyone reaches out.
Use what you know to start the conversation.
Spotting a potential trigger is just the start. If your research shows a company is having trouble reaching younger customers, skip the generic credentials presentation. Instead, share a helpful observation, a useful piece of research, or an example of how you’ve solved a similar problem.
If a company is moving into new markets, show that you understand the challenges of building awareness and preference there. Give the executive a reason to consider your point of view, even if they aren’t actively searching for an agency. That’s the difference that matters most.
Traditional prospecting usually asks, “Who might be looking for an agency?” A smarter approach is to ask, “Which companies are facing challenges we can solve, and what evidence shows those challenges are becoming priorities?” The first question helps you find prospects.
The second question can help you spot opportunities before they turn into agency searches.
What if the competition isn’t another agency?
There’s another change that could have an even bigger impact on how new business opportunities come up.
In a November 16 article, Two Marketing Conferences. One Troubling Conclusion: We’re Not Ready for AI, marketing transformation consultant Mitchell Caplan says we’re underestimating how fast AI could change marketing. After attending the ANA Masters of Marketing and ProcureCon Marketing conferences, he found that organizations are investing a lot in AI but aren’t preparing enough for what it could mean for their people, processes, structures, and agency relationships.
He points to Gartner research showing marketers are putting about 15.3% of their budgets into AI, but only 30% of CMOs say they’re truly ready for it. McKinsey found something similar: 80% of people saw productivity gains from AI, but only 37% saw a positive effect on profits.
Caplan’s point is that handing out AI tools isn’t the same as building an organization that can really use them well. He thinks the biggest changes could start reshaping marketing in the next 12 to 24 months. Consider what that might mean for agency business development.
When a CMO spots a marketing challenge, the next step might not be picking the best agency to solve it. The first question could be whether the company needs an agency at all. Could an internal team with AI handle the job? Should the company hire new talent, invest in tech, consolidate agencies, or bring in specialists?
These decisions could shift opportunities that used to lead to agency reviews. They might also create new chances for agencies with skills companies can’t easily build on their own. The challenge for agency business development is that much of this evaluation could happen internally, long before anyone knows a brand is considering a review, sends out an RFP, or reaches out to an agency.
With all the hype and worry, we still don’t know if AI will reduce the need for outside agencies or grow the market by making advanced marketing more affordable for more businesses. Both could happen, and the results will probably vary by industry, company size, and agency services.
But Caplan asks a question agency owners should consider now: Are we still building our new business programs based on how clients bought agency services in the past, while those clients are rethinking what they’ll need in the future? This highlights why it’s important to spot the signals that come before a marketing decision, not just the announcements that come after.
Here are four places I look for early signals.
Over the past year, I’ve developed a more systematic way to spot potential agency opportunities. Instead of working a prospect list, agency review announcements, and referrals, I’m focusing on four sources of intelligence that might show what companies are planning.
1. Marketing job postings and executive appointments
A new CMO has always been a sign that an agency review might be coming. A new marketing leadership role or a job description that includes agency management, vendor consolidation, market growth, or marketing transformation experience can mean more than just hiring. It might show a change in strategy, a gap in internal skills, or a rethink of current agency relationships.
2. Agency selection decisions
I’ve been following agency reviews, appointments, and when incumbents leave, focusing on why companies make these changes and how that affects earlier internal decisions. The appointment is useful to know, but the reason behind it can be even more valuable.
Was the company after new capabilities? More integration? A different cost setup? New creative ideas? Stronger data or AI skills? Better business results? Knowing what triggered the decision can help you spot other companies in similar situations.
3. Marketing and company intelligence
Traditional sources like Winmo, ZoomInfo, business reports, earnings announcements, acquisitions, management changes, and strategic funding have always been helpful for new business. But connecting the dots can tell you more. If a company is expanding into new markets, hiring senior marketing talent, and increasing investment, it’s worth a closer look. One signal alone rarely tells the whole story, but several related signals can point to a real business development opportunity.
4. Website engagement
The fourth source is right at home. If a marketing executive spends real time looking at an agency’s case studies, capabilities, or industry expertise, that could be a sign of interest worth checking out. My agency prospecting platform tracks prospects and what they’re interested in. It doesn’t prove a company is planning an agency review, but when you combine this with other information, it can help you prioritize outreach and make your conversations more relevant.
None of these signals guarantees an opportunity on its own. Their real value comes from looking at them together, spotting patterns, and learning which combinations actually lead to good conversations.
Let AI help you find new opportunities.
More and more platforms are popping up that try to connect these dots. I’ve checked out a few and haven’t been impressed. The truth is, you don’t need a pricey intelligence platform or a big research team to start trying this approach.
Here are three practical exercises any agency business development leader can try out.
1. Take a closer look at your top 25 prospects.
Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, or another AI tool to look into each company’s recent business moves, marketing leadership changes, acquisitions, product launches, and job postings.
Here’s a helpful prompt:
“Research publicly available information from the past 90 days about [company]. Identify factors that could affect its need for outside marketing expertise. Include management changes, growth challenges, acquisitions, new market entries, marketing investments, and relevant job postings. Provide dated sources, distinguish facts from assumptions, and identify evidence that might suggest the company is reducing its reliance on agencies.”
2. Spot trends throughout your industry.
Instead of looking at one company at a time, ask AI to check out developments across a category your agency knows well.
For example:
“Identify U.S. companies in [industry] that have revealed major marketing management changes, new market growth, product launches, or business challenges during the past 90 days. Explain why each development might create a need for outside agency expertise, identify relevant decision-makers, and provide supporting sources.”
Look over the results carefully. AI can spot connections worth checking out, but it can also make mistakes, miss things, or exaggerate normal business activity. Adjust the input as needed, and keep improving it as you go.
3. See if your agency would make the shortlist.
Start a new AI chat without naming your agency and ask:
“I’m a senior marketing executive at a U.S. [industry] company looking for an independent advertising agency with demonstrated expertise in [specific challenge]. Recommend five qualified agencies, explain why each belongs on the shortlist, and provide evidence supporting your recommendations.”
Try a few different versions using various business challenges and AI tools. Compare what you find with regular Google searches. If your agency doesn’t show up, dig into why. Are competitors sharing better case studies? Do they have more relevant third-party coverage? Is their positioning clearer? Does their content address the specific problems marketers are looking into?
A single search result doesn’t tell us much. But when we see the same patterns across different searches, it could point to something important. AI can’t reveal which company is quietly planning an agency review, but it can speed up research, help spot possible triggers, and find connections between business events we might otherwise miss. That’s a real step up from how we used to look for opportunities.
Is this a real trend, or just a lot of noise?
Every week, new predictions emerge about where advertising agencies are headed. Some say AI will take over creative departments. Others think brands will do everything themselves. Some believe generalists will return, while others expect specialists to take over. Some predict holding companies will merge, while others expect independent agencies to thrive.
A lot of these predictions actually contradict each other. Plus, the evidence usually comes from the biggest advertisers and agency networks, which are nothing like independent agencies with 30, 50, or 100 people.
Just because a few big agencies make headlines, there are new marketing job postings, or we hear from a few frustrated agency owners doesn’t mean there’s a real trend. To spot a true trend, we need to see the same patterns happening across different companies, industries, and over time. We also have to tell the difference between short-term moves and bigger shifts in how companies buy marketing services.
Most of all, we need proof that questions what we already believe, not just backs it up. I don’t think we have enough of that kind of evidence yet. Still, I’m sure that waiting for the whole industry to agree on what’s going on isn’t a good way to approach business development.
Preparing for whatever 2027 has in store.
I wish I could say for sure how agency business development will change in the next year. Honestly, I’d be wary of anyone who says they know. Right now, technology, client needs, company structures, and agency finances are all changing at once. Every time we think we know where things are headed, something shifts. The target keeps moving.
What I do know is that companies will keep running into marketing problems they can’t solve on their own. Agencies that offer real expertise, new ideas, and measurable results will still find opportunities.
I’m paying attention to how new opportunities will show up, who will shape the decisions, and if agencies will spot them early enough to compete. When I surveyed marketing decision-makers, I found that their preferences often form before the pitch even starts. Now, agencies have better research tools to dig into the business situations that come before those decisions and respond in the right way.
But having the tools isn’t enough. What really counts is what we look for, how we read the evidence, and what we do with what we learn. That’s why I keep working on these four sources of intelligence: looking for patterns that repeat, testing how useful they are, and sorting the real signals from the noise in our industry.
I’ll keep sharing what I find out, even when things don’t work. For now, I believe the best thing agency owners can do is stay alert, question their own assumptions, and be ready to change their business development plans as the facts become clearer.
We might not know exactly what 2027 will bring, but we can get better at spotting what’s ahead. That could turn out to be the biggest advantage in winning new business.
Happy Prospecting
If you’re looking for ways to improve your pipeline in 2027, I would be happy to share my thoughts. Find a time on my calendar: https://www.calendly.com/jheenan. Sign up for my New Business Newsletter. Please forward this post to anyone who might benefit. If you like this post, I’d appreciate a thumbs-up and a comment. Let’s also connect on LinkedIn.
#LetsGrow!
