
The ad agency sales cycle
Agency business development is a long game, unfortunately. The average client-agency relationship is about two and a half years. The average CMO tenure is between three and four years. Marketing budgets typically run for 12 months. When an agency targets clients who value the AOR model or brands with a history of long agency relationships, it can expect a long road ahead. That’s not to say there aren’t exceptions; however, agencies who need or expect fast results will likely be disappointed.
If an agency is looking at project work, the sales cycle will be much shorter. Projects are an excellent way to build trust and confidence that could lead to a longer relationship with a consistent flow of work. Sometimes, when you expect a flow of project work, it turns out to be a one-time event, making it harder for the agency to recoup its investment of time and resources. If your service offering typically has a smaller scope or cost, it will require a shorter sales cycle and higher sales volume. A well-balanced diet of projects and retainer relationships gives an agency the security and flexibility to pursue its goals.
In my experience, most agencies prefer long-term client relationships, even though trends show they’re declining. More marketers are adopting a short-term perspective because of market and economic uncertainty, C-suite impatience, and declining ad performance, resulting in shorter projects and less or no commitment to future business. Pressure on speed and cost drives creativity, innovation, and differentiation out of the equation, and the results show in performance. And AI is the rocket fuel for the decline. As this trend continues, the industry will change forever.
Over the last many years, I’ve done business development at and for a wide variety of agencies, small and large, generalists and specialists, full- and limited-service, generating millions of dollars in agency services revenue. While working with a variety of agencies, I’ve worked through the sales cycle and learned a lot. I continue to learn as the marketplace and marketers evolve, including the commoditization mentioned above, and apply those lessons to my approach and processes. One framework has helped me develop and execute more effective new business strategies.
I’ve previously written about the Prospect Opportunity Timeline (see The Prospect Opportunity Timeline), and my client engagements have proven its efficacy. My research is all fieldwork, but others have done formal studies and analysis that speak to the same. In B2B sales, such as ad agency services, copiers, or hydraulic pumps, the potential universe of buyers includes time-based behavioral segments that should guide the sales process. Unfortunately, too many agencies and salespeople use a one-size-fits-all approach and suffer the consequences.
The Prospect Opportunity Timeline maps the sales cycle and buyer journey based on timeline and buyer behavior. The buyer journey begins with a need, then research into solutions and the best companies; it continues with internal socialization, needs assessments, chemistry meetings, an RFI, a short list, an RFP, selection, negotiation, and award. Each step takes time, some more than others, particularly the beginning stage. When you overlay the buyer’s journey on your prospecting calendar, you can see how your prospecting activity aligns with that journey, or doesn’t. And given buyer behavior, 60% of a buyer’s journey is completed before they contact any agencies, which helps explain why no one is responding. (see The anatomy of a win)
Long story short, research suggests that only 3%-5% of your prospects are ready to consider your agency right now. The rest are somewhere in the process or not at all. When an agency does cold prospecting, no matter how well conceived, clever, or entertaining, it may reach only that 5% or be meaningful to them. The rest aren’t paying attention because their time has not come. It would be ideal to know what stage a prospect is in so messaging could better speak to their needs and interests. If your prospect is in the 5%, they want to know about services, cost, results, time to market, and more tactical things. If they aren’t, they will be more interested in innovation, vision, thought leadership, clever ideas, breakthrough strategies, and more conceptual thinking. Across a prospect list, your contacts will be at different stages of the journey, with different needs and interests.
Tools collect intent signals, such as a sudden increase in search activity around a particular subject, like retail media or Metaverse strategies. (See: Are you using intent data) Other events, such as a new CMO or CEO hire, typically mean the company will be changing its marketing strategy, ad strategy, and agency. Time-based events also matter, like a new budget year or product launch seasons. Winmo is a great resource for tracking trigger events like all of these. And let’s not forget networking to gather gossip and speculation about a brand’s or marketer’s intent and actions. When a marketer wants to be stealthy about their agency intentions, this kind of detective work helps to understand her intent and know how to capitalize on it.
Given this prospecting dynamic, I run a multilevel outreach program that broadly reaches across the segments I target to cast a wide net and engage those in the 3%-5% group. They will raise their hand if they want to buy and like what I’m selling. For those who aren’t ready, this broad outreach will also aim to get responses like, “Check back next year,” “We just hired a new agency,” or “We’re contracted through June.” I’ll put this feedback on the calendar and develop an individual outreach strategy for each based on their time frame. But that isn’t to reach out in June. That is a campaign that leads up to June. I want to be on their list before June, if not at the top.
The challenge, as I’m sure you’ve picked up on, is how to speak to the different buyer mindsets on your list: I need it now, I need it someday, or I’m too busy to pay attention. Of course, I’m oversimplifying for brevity, since business development has so many variables and nuances. The format of an email, InMail, or phone call can support strategic messages that speak to different mindsets within your list. It comes down to a well-crafted messaging platform that can read as a sales message if the reader wants it to. I’ll talk more about crafting the right messages in a later post.
Circling back to the Prospect Opportunity Timeline, it is a helpful tool for new business planning, and I suggest you try it as you think about your 2024 plans. Take time to map your buyer’s journey, whether you target projects or relationships, regardless of the service. Think about each step and the kind of information that your prospect seeks so you can craft messaging, content, collateral, or whatever you use to build awareness and motivate engagement. The more data-informed, personalized, and intent-driven you are, the better your results will be.
As always, I’m here if you need help.
Happy Prospecting.
If you need help planning your new business strategy for 2024, or your success rate is declining, or perhaps you are wondering what the best resource is to improve your business development process, I can help. Schedule a call. I’d be happy to share what I have learned from years of experience across hundreds of agencies, including leading business development at a variety of firms. I have a good sense of how it might apply to your circumstances.
If you like this post, click the thumbs-up so I know, then sign up for my new business newsletter. Find me on LinkedIn for daily tips, tricks, and insights. And please share your new business advice, successes, and failures. #LetsGrow!

Leave a Reply