Best of Times or Worst of Times

Best of Times or Worst of Times

Do you think this is the best or worst of times for your agency? Have you adjusted your agency’s new business strategy? If you attended any of the conferences this year, you heard about increasing competition, marathon pitches, smaller budgets, and longer decision times. Pitches are aplenty, but reviews seem to be getting longer despite smaller accounts than in years past, according to Ad Age.

Fewer full-service reviews, slowing performance marketing reviews, and pockets of activity in the social, influencer, and business-to-business spaces, industry insiders report. Pitches seem to be up overall, but their value to agencies is down as clients negotiate their compensation more sharply, says Ewan Larkin, Ad Age. 

The rise in consumer debt, interest rates, slowing consumer spending growth, GDP growth, and rising unemployment are all significant factors affecting brand spending. Agency owners’ experiences vary, with some reporting positive outcomes and others noting room for improvement. (AgencyCore, a great 2026 survey of 579 agency leaders.) Larger agencies are pursuing opportunities they might not have considered in the past, as Meghan McDonnell, president of Pile and Company, noted. Then, Stagwell Chairman and CEO Mark Penn revealed that the holding company’s new business pipeline is 50% higher than last year.

I just completed an informal analysis of small to medium-sized B2B agencies. According to LinkedIn Insights, about 90% have reduced staff by 12%—38% over the last two years. Yet last month’s job report said ad jobs hit an all-time high. 

If you are a Winmo subscriber, you know Rocket Cos., Adobe, BlackRock, Columbia Sportswear, Goodyear, McDonald’s, Northwestern Mutual, Panda Express, and many more are in review right now. MLS, Citi, Country Life, Dr. Squatch, Farmer Boys, Kenneth Cole, LPL Financial, The Maids, Wyndham Hotels & Resorts, and others just changed CMOs, so they will be in review in the next eight or so months. As seen in the industry trades, Anomaly wins AOR, BBDO wins AOR, R/GA wins creative, Publicis wins media AOR, Target drops Mother, 5W wins PR AOR, General Mills starts all agency review, W+K picks up Happy Meals, Dentsu wins creative AOR, iProspect nabs a media account, and so much more. New business activity is happening right now.

A Tale of Two Cities

Charles Dickens nailed it. “It is the best of times, it is the worst of times, it is the age of wisdom, it is the age of foolishness, it is the epoch of belief, it is the epoch of incredulity.”

How do you assess the environment, other than “crazy”? My takeaway is optimistic. I am seeing signs that the knots and kinks in the pipeline are untangling, and spending continues to move up on the cusp of what should be the most significant political ad spending in history. Not everyone will benefit, but things will look much better for the industry. This kind of crazy environment favors an agency new-business strategy that builds a strong market presence, is positioned for today’s different needs, differentiates effectively to make you an easy choice, and actively pushes content where marketing decision-makers look. 

If you are an agency on the growth side of these crazy times, kudos. I spoke with one last week who is forecasting maximum sustainable growth this year and is worried about hiring to keep up. I talked to another who is on the brink of extinction. Both asked what they should do to sustain the momentum or rekindle growth. I credit the growing agency for the question because most take their eyes off business development when times are good. I give greater credit to the other for staying in the fight. Each should follow very different new business strategies.

The Best of Times

For agencies doing well, now’s an opportune time to build a robust new business program that ensures a steady pipeline in the future. New business opportunities fluctuate constantly, and an effective program that includes organic growth, referrals, and prospecting can sustain the agency through these cycles. During up markets, the agency can experiment with new tactics and messaging, aim higher, pursue stretch targets, test adjacent verticals, and adjust sequences to manage capacity. A high-growth agency has many newsworthy stories to share that will build awareness and credibility. Such an agency should shift from a lead-gen to a demand-gen new-business strategy. 

The Worst of Times

Less fortunate agencies must focus on quick wins, high-probability prospects, results-oriented services, and easy-to-engage offers. They should focus all efforts on a lead gen agency new business strategy. For example, they need to identify sectors that are growing and spending, similar to industries they have experience in, or solutions that matter to the industry’s marketing practices, where they truly understand the business. The agency owner should use email and LinkedIn to quickly engage prospects and explain what they do and how it will help them fast. They must focus on marketers who look like their clients, who can benefit from what the agency does best, and make the cost and commitment easy to say yes to. Past clients, former employees, and vendors should be at the top of the list. 

There is an agency new business strategy for all agency situations, but it must be customized for each. Beware of charlatans who guarantee so many monthly calls or meetings. https://jheenan.com/2023/12/29/100-leads-in-your-inbox/ Beware of the AI platforms that claim to be better, faster, and higher converting. Beware of the services that force you into their template without regard to your unique qualities and culture. Regardless of the circumstances, every agency has distinctive, substantive differences and can only succeed with a business development strategy that is genuine and authentic to who they are.

If your agency is crushing it (not the iPad crushing), you are lucky to have many options to use in your new business process to make prospects seek you out. By all means, test and learn. If your agency is getting crushed, deploy a quick-win lead gen strategy to start, then morph into something more strategic when possible. Consider a parallel short- and long-term plan if your agency is somewhere between crushing and being crushed. https://jheenan.com/2023/12/27/the-prospect-opportunity-timeline/ Pursue prospects already in the market, or soon to be, with a lead gen-like approach, and use a demand gen-like approach for those who will be looking sometime in the future. But who can predict the future, especially in these crazy days? Whatever the plan, stay flexible and agile as you navigate marketplace cycles.

Go Crush It

Wherever you are with your agency new business strategy, I hope the second half generates your best results yet. I’m always open to scheduling a conversation if you need help or want to compare notes. If you like this post, sign up for my new business newsletter. Why not connect on LinkedIn to network, share resources, explore new ideas, or discuss the latest business development news? #LetsGrow!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Discover more from JHeenan Consulting

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading