After working with more than 50 agencies of all shapes and sizes, I’ve learned that the key to consistent growth is simple: early planning. And September is the ideal time to take control of your agency’s future. Yes, September. Why? Because it’s the bold approach that sets successful agencies apart.
Agencies that take this window seriously enter the new year with clarity, focus, and momentum. Agencies that don’t? They’re left chasing scraps, reacting to RFPs, and wondering why their pipeline is empty.
Here’s the framework I use with my clients to build a new business plan that actually delivers.
September: Assess the Year Honestly
This isn’t a box-checking exercise. It’s about facing the facts.
- Prospecting: Did your outreach bring in the right conversations, just a lot of noise, or crickets? One client I worked with had a steady stream of calls, spent time prepping, only to find that 80% could never afford them. Their outreach was too generic, and their list too loose.
- Organic growth: Did your account people create upsell opportunities? One agency thought their largest client was maxed out, until we uncovered an entire business unit no one had ever talked to. That move ended up being their biggest revenue jump of the year.
- Referrals/networking: Did they actually convert? A leadership team I worked with prided themselves on “a strong referral culture.” Their data showed referrals brought conversations, but not business. That made me rethink their follow-up and develop a strategy and cadence to turn those warm intros into revenue when the timing was right.
The goal in September is to pull the year apart and find out where you’re actually winning, where you’re wasting time, and where you’re blind.
October: Scan the Landscape
Once you know where you stand, you must understand what you’re up against. Agencies don’t operate in a vacuum. Your prospects are facing new pressures, your competition is shifting, and the marketplace is evolving.
- Industry shifts: AI and automation aren’t optional; they reshape expectations. More RFPs are asking AI questions and requiring AI capabilities. If you’re not clear on where you fit in that conversation, prospects will assume you’re behind. If your website doesn’t communicate it, you may never know you were passed up.
- Marketer mindset: At a recent conference, a CMO told me bluntly, “I’m tired of agencies telling me they’re strategic partners. Show me how you can move revenue next quarter.” That bar has moved. Scan the industry to confirm or update what marketers are looking for and how you can fit their needs.
- Competition: Procurement is consolidating rosters. In-housing continues to chip away at tactical work. AI is eating more than crumbs. Creators are taking more of your budget. That means differentiation isn’t a luxury; it’s survival. Agencies have to embrace the changes and operate above it all.
Use October to gather intelligence. Read the trades, talk to peers, have one-on-ones with your leadership, and listen to what clients are actually saying. Then translate it into opportunity.
November: Build the Plan
With that context, it’s time to decide how you’ll win.
- Positioning: One digital agency I worked with described themselves as “full-service.” Prospects shrugged. We repositioned them as the go-to partner for SaaS growth marketing. Within six months, their win rate doubled. Focus your positioning on the audiences you serve and the problems you solve better than anyone else.
- Prospects: Don’t just make a list of companies you “like.” Define your ideal client profile (ICP), sector, budget, growth stage, culture fit, and any other way you can slice it. The best agencies get hyper-specific. Focus on your three best industries to start.
- Budget: Allocate for training, tools, data, travel, and prospecting support. Agencies that don’t budget for new business are the ones that cut corners, and it shows. Agencies aiming for hyper-growth should invest 20% or more of their revenue in marketing and business development.
Draft it, debate it, pressure-test it. Then commit.
December: Get the Tools Ready
December is chaotic: billing, year-end projects, closing the books, and holidays. But you still need to produce the actual assets that will support your new outreach strategy on day one:
- Updated case studies (not 3 years old)
- Landing pages that convert
- Thought leadership you can distribute
- Prospect lists that are clean, current, and decision-maker focused
Many clients I’ve worked with waited until February or March to refresh their website. By the time it went live, Q1 was gone. Break those bad habits.
January: Execute with Confidence
If you’ve done the work, you start the year with confidence and momentum. While your competitors are still making their “New Year’s resolutions,” you’re already charging into the new year, reaching the right prospects with the right message.
Don’t Get to it Later
Some agencies will skim this and convince themselves they’ll “get to it later.” They won’t. January will arrive, and they’ll be chasing cold RFPs, reacting to bad fits and random opportunities, wondering why the year feels off balance from day one.
The agencies that treat September as the starting line and stick to the schedule will be ready on New Year’s Day. They’ll know exactly who they’re targeting, how they’re positioned, what to say, and what tools they need. They’ll already be executing when the new year hits. That early start gives them a significant competitive advantage, while their competitors are still catching up.
Preparation doesn’t guarantee growth. But lack of preparation almost always guarantees struggle. One group will be ready. The other will be reacting. Which are you?
Happy Planning
If you want help planning for next year, set up a call. I always enjoy exploring what’s new, what’s working, and what isn’t. Find a time on my calendar, and let’s solve those nagging business development problems that keep you from having your best year yet. If you like this post, give it a thumbs up, forward it to a friend, and leave a comment. Don’t forget to sign up for my New Business Newsletter. While you are at it, let’s connect on LinkedIn. agency new business consultant
#LetsGrow!
Leave a Reply