
Is Ad Agency BD Harder Today
Is ad agency business development harder today than ten years ago? The 80:20 rule suggests so. In a recent discussion with a friend in the business, we found ourselves at opposite ends of the spectrum. To delve deeper, I reached out to thirty agency owners and GMs. The results were a mixed bag, but one thing was clear-only about 20% found the business environment to be the same or easier than a decade ago. In the 80:20 rule, the top 20% win 80% of the business, highlighting the need for effective business development strategies to be part of that top 20%.
These five comments from the 80% echo the shared struggles of many in the industry.
- “We’ve tried everything – cold calls, emails, social media, LinkedIn. But our pipeline is as dry as the moon. Where are all the leads hiding?” Full-service Agency
- “I’m pulling out whatever hair I’ve got left. We’re great at what we do, but no one seems to know we exist. How are we supposed to grow without new clients?” Branding Agency
- “It feels like we’re shouting into the wind. What do we have to show for all this effort in business development? Zilch.” Media Agency
- “I didn’t start an agency to become a full-time salesperson. But here I am, chasing leads that never materialize. There has to be a better way.” Digital Agency
- “Our creative work is top-notch, but our new business efforts are a complete flop. It’s like we’re invisible. Is it the BD person or the BD strategy? I’m at my wit’s end.” Creative Agency
These quotes, while kept anonymous, reflect the common challenges faced by many agency owners, and confirm that ad agency BD is harder today. The issues they grapple with, such as a soft economy, inflation, high labor costs, increasing competition, wary marketing decision-makers, and impatient C-suites, are not unique. In fact, they are greater today than anyone can remember, impacting most agencies. This shared experience can help you feel less isolated in your struggles.
If you think about it from a macro perspective across the agency spectrum, 80% of owners or GMs are unhappy with their new business performance. That’s a big chunk. Some are on the verge of extinction, others are struggling to make a profit, and a few are doing well but unhappy that they aren’t doing better. Overall, it speaks to the bigger question of why agencies are so good at what they do for their clients and so bad about doing the same for themselves.
Earlier in my career, I worked at various agencies. I still remember being shocked that talented people could come up with incredible solutions for clients but were clueless about generating sales for their agency. That’s the primary reason I became a consultant and why I always structure my engagements with the end in mind. I design a custom new business program for the agency, run it for them to optimize the results and prove its success, and then train them to keep it going. I believe in teaching them to fish, not relying on someone like me to bring them fish. Once they feel confident enough to take over, I fade out.
The primary goal of this post is to provide practical solutions to those who feel that ad agency BD is harder today, including those I’ve quoted. I’ll take the five quotes, extract the prevailing issue or challenge from each, and then list the top things I would do to solve it. I know agencies usually deal with multiple problems and can pull suggested solutions as needed. Remember, if it’s too overwhelming, tangled up, or you lack the people or skills, I’m just a phone call away. There’s always a solution, and I’m here to help you find it.
1. A Dry Pipeline
Let’s take it from the top. The first quote references a pipeline as dry as the moon. That’s a familiar problem for most agencies at some point. A lack of lead flow means you aren’t visible to your market, you don’t offer what your market wants, or your brand and positioning make you look outdated or irrelevant. The first thing that needs to be done is assessing your website, positioning, and service offerings to ensure you are up-to-date, relevant, competitive, and offering value to your target audience. Once that is done, you need to grow awareness.
The easiest way to increase awareness is to implement a content marketing strategy. Start by brainstorming your ideal client and their pain points. Use that exercise to guide the creation of valuable, relevant content that addresses these issues across various formats—blog posts, whitepapers, videos, and podcasts. Distribute this content through your website, social media channels, and email newsletters everywhere you think you might encounter your target audience.
The next thing to consider is a referral and recommendation program. Consider incentives for clients and connections who refer new business, such as discounts on future services, cash, or something else. Make it easy to refer you by providing them with materials that showcase your work and explain your services and talking points to start the conversation. Help them understand who in their network might be a good referral and how to identify someone at a convention or afterparty. Keep your network informed about the agency to stay top of mind.
Speaking of your network, you should attend as many industry events and conferences as possible that your prospects will participate in to get introductions, networking, and overall awareness of your agency. Focus on those events that are likely to attract your target audience. Once you’ve committed to attending, scan your networks to see if anyone might also be attending or want to join you. Don’t go it alone. Attend with someone from your agency. Two heads are better than one, and four feet can cover more of the show floor.
2. Lack of Visibility
In addition to the tactics mentioned above, there are other ways to raise your visibility and relevance. I’m sure you know this, but improving SEO begins with keyword research to understand what your potential clients are searching for. It’s essential to do this regularly as trends and keywords change. If you haven’t updated yours in a while, get to it. Optimize your website content, meta descriptions, and headlines with new keywords. Create high-quality, relevant content regularly to boost your search rankings.
Updating your case studies is another way to shape the agency’s perception. If you haven’t added to or replaced your case studies in years, you’ve got important work to do. Select your most recent client projects. Write detailed accounts of the challenge, your solution, and the measurable results. If you don’t have access to results, speak to the overall growth or success that your work helped to achieve. Include client testimonials and strong visual elements. Video is essential to showcase. Feature these prominently on your website in pitches, proposals, blogs, and social media.
It would help if you also tried participating in speaking engagements or webinars targeting your ideal prospects. You can explore collaborations with complementary businesses for co-marketing opportunities. Any time you insert yourself into conversations that appeal to your prospects, you will raise your agency’s visibility.
3. Ineffective Outreach
No matter what you try, you get little or nothing back from your outreach, which is why ad agency BD is harder than ever. This is likely because of the issues mentioned in number one. If no one knows you, why would they respond? Your target audience already knows some agencies, and unless you can make a strong case for why you are a better choice, you will continue to shout into the wind. Essential to this is differentiation, finding a way to stand apart from the competition and position the agency as the best solution for your prospect’s needs.
Refining your unique value proposition requires an astute understanding of your target market and competitors. Compare and contrast them to identify what proveably sets you apart—your process, results, industry expertise, or something else. Craft a clear, compelling, assertive statement that communicates this uniqueness succinctly, then weave it through everything and share frequently.
For personalized outreach, invest time in researching each prospect before contacting them. Look at their website, recent news, social media presence, and industry challenges. This information will tailor your outreach, showing them you aren’t just another cold caller. Demonstrate that you know them and explain how your agency will address their needs or opportunities.
To make this manageable, marketing automation tools should be used to scale, improve efficiency, and ensure follow-up. Use it to implement a lead nurturing strategy with valuable content and consistent touches. The adage, out of sight, out of mind, is as true today. You need a constant drumbeat in the proper channels to positively shape your prospect’s perception of the agency and be present when a need arises.
4. Overreliance on the Owner
This may not be an issue for everyone, but for those who are, it can be a bigger problem than you know. We only have so many hours in the day. If you have to run the agency and chase new business, neither will turn out well. That’s not to say you shouldn’t be involved. Of course, you should, but not running the day-to-day. Leaders have to delegate BD responsibilities.
You can divide the responsibilities among your senior team or hire a dedicated business development professional. In either case, create a detailed job description outlining responsibilities and required skills to clarify roles, responsibilities, and accountability. If hiring, look for candidates with a track record in agency sales and a strong network in your target industries. Consider offering a competitive salary with performance-based bonuses to attract top talent.
Your instincts and expertise are valuable, and you should use them to train existing team members in networking, relationship building, and sales through a comprehensive training program. Cover topics like prospecting, pitching, objection handling, and closing techniques. Provide ongoing support through regular role-playing exercises, shadowing opportunities with experienced sales staff, and feedback sessions.
Over time, you and your team should develop a straightforward sales process and playbook so that other members and new hires can step in and contribute to the agency’s growth. Consider outside training or partnering with sales agencies or consultants to improve everyone’s game. Every staff member should be included and encouraged to network, participate in, and support the sales effort.
5. Is it the BD Person or BD Strategy
The first thing an agency chief wonders when ad agency BD is harder is who’s to blame. Too often, the BD person takes the fall when there are other factors at work. When doing postmortems, the BD person has little to do with the decision not to engage or go with another agency. It’s almost always a strategic issue.
What matters is a vibrant agency brand with well-defined core values, mission, and expertise, a brand that is reinforced in its marketing materials, website, pitch decks, staff, and work. It’s communicated with a distinctive visual identity and tone of voice that conveys confidence, vision, and authority that sets the agency apart from competitors.
It’s fortified through client testimonials and endorsements. Make them a standard part of your account management process. Create a simple form or questionnaire for clients to fill out, asking about their experience and results. Better yet, try to do it through video testimonials. Offer to send a professional videographer to their office. Make it clear how much you value their feedback and how it helps your business grow.
Enter industry awards to gain recognition. Create thought leadership content to demonstrate expertise and vision. Include a relevant client in the missive for greater credibility and relatability. And be sure to leverage strong keywords for greater reach and consistency.
When ad agency BD is harder and the challenges of agency business development can sometimes feel overwhelming, it’s important to remember that you’re not alone in this struggle. The landscape may have changed, but opportunities still abound for agencies willing to adapt and persevere.
Remember why you started your agency in the first place – your passion, creativity, and desire to make a difference for clients. That same drive should fuel your business development efforts. Passion is infectious to your employees and future clients. It’s about harnessing your strengths and applying them in new ways to connect with potential clients.
Success in new business rarely happens overnight. It’s a continuous improvement process that involves learning and refining your approach. Every pitch, conversation, and content you create is an opportunity to improve and move closer to your goals.
Don’t be afraid to experiment and try new tactics. What worked a decade ago may not be as effective now, but that opens the door to innovation. Your agency’s ability to adapt and find new creative solutions is one of its greatest assets—apply that same thinking to your business development strategy.
Lastly, celebrate your wins, no matter how small. Landing a new client, getting positive feedback on a pitch, or even just making a promising new connection are all steps in the right direction. These successes build momentum and confidence, leading to even greater achievements.
The ad agency world has always been dynamic and challenging. But it’s also filled with passionate, creative people who know how to solve problems—these problems. By focusing on your unique strengths, continuously refining your approach, and staying persistent, you can overcome these hurdles and set your agency on a path to sustained growth and success.
Happy Prospecting!
When ad agency BD is harder today than ever things must change. If it isn’t integral to your day-to-day agency operations, it can be overwhelming, erratic, understaffed, and ineffective. I always enjoy chatting about what I do and how I can help. If you need help, schedule a call. While you are at it, let’s connect on LinkedIn. Don’t miss more content like this. Sign up for my New Business newsletter.
#LetsGrow!

Leave a Reply